Defining Revolution Second Generation Theorists Essay

1600 words - 7 pages

Defining Revolution
Second Generation Theorists
Both Samuel Huntington and Charles Tilley are considered to be a part of the second generation of theorists that deal with the issue of revolution. These theorists view revolutions in conjunction with a pluralist approach which considers events to be the outcome of conflict between competing interest groups428*. Both theorists viewed revolutions as the ultimate political conflict which would ultimately destroy the political system to which the revolution was opposed. In order for a revolutionary situation to occur multiple sovereignty must be present; that is highly opposed competing interest groups must exist within a state and must both have the necessary resources to attempt to achieve their revolutionary goals*.
Huntington defines revolution as the result of a state in which rapid mobilisation of new groups and social change is taking place while the necessary organisational organs are unable to appease the wants of the people and provide change at a matched pace 430*. The effect of such mass mobilisation and the significant increase in political participation intends to destabilise the current political institutions within the state. During phases of modernisation, Huntington suggests that such expansion should be matched with similar paced development of political institutions in terms of their complexity and autonomy in order to minimise and contain the effect of modernisation by political institutions*. Huntington equates modernisation with political decay and therefore suggests criteria by which political institutions can attempt to maintain political relevance. These criteria include; complexity, autonomy, coherence and adaptability. It is suggested by Huntington that if a political institution adapts to the changing needs of its people, maintains its power and relevance and ensures consistency, it will endure the possible political catalysed by modernisation431*.
Few criticisms are offered in response to Huntington’s theory pf revolution; too few studies have been conducted to conclusively confirm whether or not instability resulting from modernisation is actually directly linked to the rate of modernisation as suggested432*. In order to ensure that revolution is adequately removed from other similar phenomena, Huntington provides the following definition of revolutions: “a revolution is a rapid, fundamental, and violent domestic change in the dominant values and myths of a society, in its political institutions, social structure, leadership, and government activity and policies.” Huntington inflates the definition to such an extent that it can be argued that no such revolution has ever occurred433*. Despite the abovementioned criticism, Huntington’s theory of revolution offers an alternative theory to psychologism, often employed when explaining revolution as well as a view that considers the importance of group claims on the political system431*.
Charles Tilley suggests that a...

Find Another Essay On Defining Revolution- Second Generation Theorists

The Key Differences Between Realists, Morality of State Theorists, and Cosmopolitans

1719 words - 7 pages the instance of secession, or when there isn’t a fit between the government and its respective community. The second is civil war and when one or more parties intervene in support of one side; another state has the right to intervene to support the other party. Lastly, intervention is justified when a government is engaged in the “massacre or enslavement of its own citizens or subjects” (Walzer 61). Walzer and other morality of state theorists

Morality of Premarital Sex by Religiosity and Generation

8743 words - 35 pages (Bedard, 2001, p1). This generation was the first to be represented within television in the forms of many shows such as Party of Five, My So-Called Life, and Melrose Place. This is the first generation to experience MTV and the Fox Network, and, as a result, it is much more aware of America's diversity. Because of this awareness, this generation is highly accepting of others and their differences (“Defining Generation X TV,” 2001, p1). Generation

Labeling Theory

3497 words - 14 pages (1966). He questions the success of the labelling theorists in terms of how they interpret the defining of behaviour as deviant, as well as, how much study is actually done in this area. In addition, Becker (1963) goes out of his way to explain the underlying problems of labelling theory. First of all, he suggests that there are not enough studies of deviant behaviour. He further implies that there are not enough studies of enough kinds of deviant

Critical Theory- A Social Theory

1690 words - 7 pages of the leading members of the institute and they were also the first generation of theorist. (Kellner, 1992), and one of the major contributors of this institute is Felix Weil; he was a German Marxist who was determined to introduce Marxist studies in Germany and his donations to the Frankfurt School of thought were very helpful in establishing the institute. A background in Marxist philosophy helped the Frankfurt School theorists improve their

China's Culture Revolution

1334 words - 5 pages that an estimated one million people was killed during the Culture revolution (Meisner, 354). The Chinese Communist Party openly admitted it was a mistake after Deng XiaoPing came to power. The Culture Revolution also sacrificed an entire generation of young intellectuals because Mao ZeDong called on them to leave the cities and reform their thinking in villages doing hard labor. (Wong, 120) These same young intellectuals today are being dismissed

The Case of Evolutionism vs. Creationism

1094 words - 4 pages judicial game of chess. In this dissertation, several items will be discussed: First, the First Amendment of the United States Constitution will be defined, specifically with how it has been interpreted on the issue of religious freedom; second, the theories of evolutionism and creationism will be discussed, defining both, while showing they opposite viewpoints; last several Supreme Court decisions will be discussed pertaining to the

The Storming of Bastille

1381 words - 6 pages are successful it is something I can show to the next generation. Only the most defining moments of this revolution shall go in here. Celebration and rejoice followed the success, with the heads getting carried across and around Paris to show that change had begun. I along with a few others went to the royal court, to merely tell the king the recent event s and the crowd’s demands. As we explained, he replied in a wine filled breath “so it is a

Positive Outcomes of the French Revolution

1855 words - 7 pages . Even though theorists have divergent opinions on the factors that started the rebellion, there are three widely accepted causes: financial status of the country, rapid overpopulation, and the relative unfairness of the French political system (“French Revolution,” Columbia). The French government was in great debt because it had assisted America in the American Revolution in the 1770s. Moreover, the underclass, made mostly of peasants and manual

Globalisation What difficulties are there in defining globalisation? To what extent is globalization in the late twentieth century a new trend? Outline the debates regarding the economic benefits of...

1241 words - 5 pages inherent in defining globalisation. These theorists observed that globalisation theories draw on a variety of different and sometimes conflicting perspectives, that the nature of globalisation is reliant upon one's theoretical point of view. Furthermore, depending upon the observer's preferences, globalisation can be understood and interpreted differently and that there is no concession on a common explanation of the nature of globalisation.The

The Impact of the Sexual Revolution on Choices Related to Sex

2154 words - 9 pages ) The major shift towards human sexuality in America began in the 1960’s, and continued strongly throughout till the 1980’s; this specific period of time has been referred to as the American Sexual Revolution. The sexual revolution was brought about through the fluctuation of the American environment; World War 2, psychological and technological advances gave way to the shift in values, attitudes and beliefs towards human sexuality which has

The Divisons Within Canada

2981 words - 12 pages quite apparent among immigrants and poses a threat to commonality in Canada. The cultural mosaic is due to the fact that these cultures do not integrate themselves into Canada not only because they have a right to, but also because they have the ability to. The second generation immigrants are the ones becoming saturated with Canada's culture through the educational system and the media. '[N]either the state nor the

Similar Essays

Examination Of Factors That Begin Revolutions

3250 words - 13 pages circumstances in which revolution is likely to occur and attempt to explain the question of why there is variance in revolutions. So what exactly is a revolution? Peter Calvert (2002: 303) describes revolution as `violence plus political change: it brings about a fall of government or a change of regime'. However the revolutions of Eastern Europe in 1989 dispute this definition as in some cases no violence was used. The defining feature of revolution

Industry, Ideology, And Their Global Impact, 1700

1242 words - 5 pages generation following Butterfield's classic survey much was written to develop and improve the vision. Moreover, there are good rationales. Since the Scientific Revolution is the known origin of the history of science, it was the first area to gain from the professionalization of the field, from its growing specialization, variety of methods, and from the real-time expansion of scale and reduction of focus motivated by sociologists and theorists of

The Steam Engine Essay

852 words - 3 pages . Improving on Trevithick's machine, George Stevenson built a better locomotive, known as the "rocket", that could move six cars of coal and twenty-one passenger coaches at faster speed in 1830. In addition, steam-powered ships would gradually replace sail ships. To elaborate further on the steam engine effects, the epitome of its social impact can be seen during the Industrial Revolution. People of this generation preceding the steam engine were

Industrial Revolution Essay

1472 words - 6 pages adulthood years. The four generations that I want to describe are the GI, Baby boomers, Generation X, and the Echo Boomers. I believe that the differences of opinion in these four generations with clearly show the path to understand the definition of the family for the future. The GI generation (born before 1940) was shaped by the Second World War, respect for hierarchy, men were the breadwinners while wife’s tended to the household, and had a